Carbon risk resolution vote results

COMPANY

2016

2017

49%

67%

Occidental Petroleum

38%

62%

ExxonMobil

43%

57%

PPL Corporation

30%

46%

Southern Company

45%

26%

DTE Energy

23%

40%

Devon Energy

22%

38%

Kinder Morgan

Carbon risk resolution vote results

COMPANY

2016

2017

49%

67%

Occidental Petroleum

38%

62%

ExxonMobil

43%

57%

PPL Corporation

30%

46%

Southern Company

45%

DTE Energy

26%

23%

40%

Devon Energy

Kinder Morgan

22%

38%

Carbon risk resolution vote results

COMPANY

2016

2017

49%

67%

Occidental Petroleum

38%

62%

ExxonMobil

43%

57%

PPL Corporation

30%

46%

Southern Company

45%

DTE Energy

26%

23%

40%

Devon Energy

Kinder Morgan

22%

38%

Carbon risk resolution vote results

2016

2017

49%

67%

Occidental Petroleum

38%

62%

ExxonMobil

43%

57%

PPL Corporation

30%

46%

Southern Company

45%

DTE Energy

26%

23%

40%

Devon Energy

Kinder Morgan

22%

38%

Carbon risk resolution vote results

2016

2017

49%

67%

Occidental Petroleum

38%

62%

ExxonMobil

43%

57%

PPL Corporation

30%

46%

Southern Company

45%

DTE Energy

26%

23%

40%

Devon Energy

Kinder Morgan

22%

38%